In the shadow of Justice

Today, August 16th, UNC’s great All America end Art Weiner celebrates his 86th birthday.  Weiner and teammate Charlie Justice were UNC’s “Touchdown Twins” of the late 1940s.  Justice, the tailback in Coach Carl Snavely’s famous single wing formation got most of the headlines.  Weiner would have received just as many accolades—maybe more—had he been on any other team without Justice.  Hugh Morton collection volunteer Jack Hilliard takes a look back at the Weiner-Justice connection during the golden era of Carolina football.

UNC football team, 1949
Charlie Justice (22) and Art Weiner (50), lead the UNC football team onto the field at Kenan Stadium, 1949.

He was the perfect fit.  Art Weiner, with his wit and sense of humor, was the perfect “Roaster” for a series of Charlie Justice charity roasts during the early 1980s—one in Greensboro for multiple sclerosis, one in Asheville for the Western Carolina Children’s Foundation, and one in Charlotte for juvenile diabetes.  Weiner had tales to tell on his longtime friend and teammate.  A favorite story went something like this:

My mother-in-law never understood all of the hype about Charlie Choo Choo Justice.  She said, “If he’s as good as all the newspaper headlines say he is, why doesn’t he just go out on the field by himself and win the game, and all of you guys can just stand and watch?”
Well, at the 1949 Carolina–Duke game over in Durham I had a great day.  I caught two touchdown passes, and blocked the Duke field goal attempt in the final seconds to save the game.  So, when I got home that night I called my mother-in-law and said, “Be sure and check tomorrow’s paper . . . see who makes the headlines this time.”

Next morning, Weiner rushed out to get the morning paper off the front porch.  He ran inside and opened it up to the sports section and there it was, the headline from Saturday’s game: “Justice Scores One, Passes For Two, Leads Tar Heels Over Duke.”

In the fall of 1946, Art Weiner and Charlie Justice, through one of those quirks of fate that often happens in the world of sports, found themselves together on the practice field in Chapel Hill.  Both had played service football during World War II—Weiner in the Marines and Justice in the Navy.  Both had played in Hawaii.  Immediately they became friends, on and off the playing field.  It was on the field where they made headlines.

Charlie Justice and Art Weiner, 1949
Charlie Justice and Art Weiner, 1949.

The first game of the golden era of Carolina football came against Virginia Tech (called VPI in those days) on September 28, 1946.  On the second UNC series of that game, Weiner caught a 9-yard touchdown pass from Bill Maceyko.  It was Weiner’s first college play.  He went on to score three more times in ’46 despite several injuries.  In 1947 Weiner caught 19 passes for 396 yards, but it was 1948 when he was selected to Grantland Rice’s All America team.
When UNC alums, fans, and friends get together, they often look back at great Carolina wins.  Two games from 1948 almost always come up: the Texas game and the Duke game.  When Texas came to town on September 25th, Weiner had a touchdown on Carolina’s third play from scrimmage, and the Heels went on to win 34 to 7.  In the Duke game, 44,500 fans—in perfect Kenan Stadium weather—saw Weiner catch two touchdown passes: one for 13 yards from Justice, and another for 26 yards from fullback Hosea Rodgers.  It was Justice’s 43-yard touchdown run in the third quarter, however, that made all the headlines.
In addition to the Duke game that he described at the Justice roast, the 1949 season saw Weiner play a great game against NC State and have a fantastic day against the University of Georgia in Chapel Hill catching six passes—two for touchdowns.  He was selected lineman of the week by the Associated Press.  Head Coach Wally Butts, the Hall of Fame Bulldog main man, in an interview following Carolina’s win, said, “Art Weiner is the greatest pass catching end I’ve ever seen.”
Art Weiner catching pass versus Georgia.
UNC left end Art Weiner catches pass during game against Georgia at Kenan Stadium, September 27, 1947. UNC tailback Charlie Justice (left) looks on from a distance while Georgia's Dan Edwards (#55) watches from a few yards away.

Justice talked at length about his friend and teammate in the locker room following the ’49 Georgia game.  “Boy, that Art was terrific today.  Did you see him fake that safety man on the first touchdown?  I almost had to laugh when I threw the ball.  And that last (winning) touchdown?  Why, that was a run which would ordinarily take both a halfback and a fullback to make.  The guy’s terrific.”
Charlie Justice and Art Weiner in locker room
Charlie Justice and Art Weiner shake hands in a locker room after a 1949 UNC football game (negative P0081 6.2.1-1-279, cropped).

Orville Campbell, writing in The Carolina Gridiron magazine, compared Weiner to another great Carolina end, Andy Bershak.  Against NC State, Weiner had seven catches which prompted State Head Coach Beattie Feathers to conclude,  “I’m thankful that I’ll never have to set up another defense to try and stop Weiner and Justice.  They’re uncanny.”
Art Weiner (#50) with ball; NC State Full Back Paul Bruno (#32).
Art Weiner with ball eluding North Carolina State fullback Paul Bruno, 24 September 1949.

When the 1949 season ended, Weiner had 52 catches to lead the nation in receptions.  He was again selected to All America teams and was a unanimous choice for the first annual Senior Bowl game played in Jacksonville’s Gator Bowl on January 7, 1950, where he caught eight passes for 139 yards and was lineman of the game.
Art WeinerIt was not surprising when Weiner was the first round NFL draft pick on January 20, 1950 of the New York Yankees.  (Yes, there was a New York Yankees pro football team in 1950.)  During the ’50 season, he caught 35 passes for 722 yards and 6 touchdowns.  His pro career, however, was cut short by a knee injury.  He coached briefly at Kings Mountain High School, and then joined Burlington Industries as a vice president for manufacturing services where he remained for 23 years.
Although they went their separate ways following their time at UNC, Weiner and Justice remained steadfast friends through the years.  The 1946-49 era UNC players held reunions from time to time, and Weiner and Justice were always there leading the cheers.  There were celebrity golf tournaments . . . there was even a UNC football alumni basketball team called the Carolina Clowns.
When the North Carolina Sports Hall of Fame inducted Weiner in 1974, Justice was at the ceremony cheering for his friend.  In June 1981 Art Weiner Travel, Inc. of Greensboro established a branch office in Greenville that was jointly owned by Charlie Justice.  In December 1992 when the National Football Foundation College Football Hall of Fame inducted Art Weiner, Charlie Justice was there in Art’s shadow.  Charlie Justice and Art Weiner made their final appearance together on the field at Kenan Stadium on November 16, 2001 at the Justice Era Reunion.  It would be Charlie’s final visit to Chapel Hill.

Meanwhile . . . back at the roast . . . Weiner asked the question:

Did you ever wonder why there are so many fantastic Hugh Morton action pictures of Charlie Justice?  Well, Hugh Morton was a world class, fantastic photographer, but there is another reason.  We had one member on our team who never touched the ball . . . never made a tackle . . . never threw a block.  His only purpose in life was to let Charlie Justice know where Hugh Morton was on the sidelines.

The young man did a good job.  There are dozens of Justice (and Weiner) action shots—not all of which are online—in the Hugh Morton collection at Wilson Library on the UNC campus.
Here’s a postscript for UNC trivia fans: What year did Charlie Justice complete his final pass to Art Weiner on the field at Kenan Stadium?

17 thoughts on “In the shadow of Justice”

  1. Picture #4 in this post has an interesting history. There are at least four different poses that have been published over the years…including one on page 108 of the UNC 2012 Football Media Guide; however, this is the first time I’ve seen one with Weiner wearing his helmet.

  2. The focus on the fourth photograph is a bit soft, plus outside of my cropping there is a young fellow behind Justice’s right shoulder and on the far left is a player beginning to undress from the game—all reasons this version may not have seen the light of day until now. I didn’t see other versions of this scene that you mentioned, Jack, but on the other hand there are *a lot* of football negatives for these years and I didn’t go through all of them.

  3. Interesting, Stephen. Most of those other versions of picture #4 have been published in media guides and game programs; however, there is an image in Hugh’s 1988 book, “Making A Difference in North Carolina” on page 259. That picture is often cropped as a Justice/Weiner two-shot.

  4. The State of North Carolina has lost a treasure. The University of North Carolina has lost a legend. Art Weiner passed away on Christmas night at The Moses H. Cone Memorial Hospital in Greensboro.
    If you were a football fan during the late 1940s and early 1950s, you know Art Weiner. He, along with his dear friend Charlie Justice, became All America at UNC in ’48 and ’49 and will forever be linked to the “Golden Era” of Carolina athletics.
    Art Weiner was 87 years old.
    Weiner was also Hugh Morton’s friend and was often a photo subject.

  5. Journalist Matt Morgan has an excellent article on Art Weiner in the Summer (2014) issue of “Inside Carolina” magazine. (Pages 78-81)
    There are two Morton photographs to support the piece. (Pages 78-79) (Cropped) (Page 80)
    (This comment was originally posted on August 12, 2014 at approximately 12:34 PM)

  6. In the early 1950’s (Choo Choo) Charlie Justice and Art Weiner, (Snatchet) along with numerous members from the UNC football team played basketball on a team called the Carolina Clowns. There were 4 teams consisting of football players, UNC, NC State, Wake Forest & Duke. They often played at charity events etc., in small towns. I located a newspaper article from The Duplin Times dated Feb. 17, 1950 advertising the Carolina Clowns playing against the Beulaville All-Stars the following night. On a national level and in any of their biographies, I’ve not found any reference to this. Has anyone else? I would love to know more.

  7. Thank you very much, Karen for your remembering the Carolina Clowns and sharing your comment on the “View to Hugh” web site.
    I don’t know of a good source for Carolina Clowns’ information, but I’m glad to share what little I recall…thanks to my boyhood Charlie Justice scrapbook.
    If memory serves, the Carolina Clowns were former in 1949 and offered former Tar Heel athletes an opportunity to stay in shape and at the same time raise money for various charity events. They played until the middle 1950s.
    Over the years the Clowns’ roster changed from time to time as new players became available and others moved on to other things. Here is a list of some of the Clowns;
    UNC Football Players: Charlie Justice, Art Weiner, Bob Cox, Joe Wright, Jim Camp, Kenny Powell, Sid Varney, Don Hartig, Hosea Rodgers, Jack Fitch
    UNC Basketball Players: Bob Paxton, Bud Maddie, John “Hook” Dillon,
    UNC Swimmer and Diver: Darrell Artry Byerly
    Media Player: Bob Quincy, Sports Editor, “The Charlotte Observer”
    Some of the charity games similar to the one you mention with the Beulaville All-Stars, included a game against Bones McKinney’s Durham High All-Stars in Durham with money going to the March of Dimes. Bones scored 16 points that night while Justice got only 2 and Weiner got 5, but the Clowns won the game 46 to 39.
    There was a game in the Charlotte Armory against the Charlotte Parks & Recreation All-Stars…a game that the Clowns won 62 to 39. The Clowns were coached that night by George (Rocky) Sparger, former Tar Heel football player. The Charlotte paper reported that Sports Editor Bob Quincy failed to score taking 3 ¾ shots…the final shot missed everything by 5 feet. The charity that night was the Boy Scout Council camp building fund. The second game of the night featured the UNC Freshmen against the Davidson College Freshmen. Two names on the UNC Freshmen team that night were Lennie Rosenbluth and Joe Quigg. Three years later, they would lead the Tar Heels to that perfect 1957 National Championship season.
    The game I remember most took place on Saturday, February 16, 1954 in the Reynolds High School Gym with the Clowns playing the Winston-Salem City Coaches. The reason I remember so much about this game…I was there.
    One of the largest crowds in Reynolds Gym history, 2,200 packed the building and saw the Clowns win by two points, 57 to 55. The charity on this night was the March of Dimes. The Clowns were coached by Sammy Sanders, a Carolina athlete who was stricken with polio in 1952, while the Winston-Salem Coaches team was coached by Tom Cash, a veteran Twin City coach at Gray High School. For this game, the Clowns picked up some local athletes…Fred Bauer, Sonny Ridenhour and Ernie Shore.
    The game was close most of the way…at the end of the first quarter, the score was tied 13 to 13. The teams were never separated by more than three points in the second quarter with the Clowns leading 28 to 27 at the half.
    Late in the third quarter, with the score tied at 41, Charlie Justice hit a long set shot to give the Clowns a 43 to 41 lead to end the quarter. (When was the last time you saw anyone shoot a set shot…maybe never, unless you’re old like me).
    In the final quarter, Art Weiner led the Clowns with three baskets late in the game and Justice hit another long set-shot to seal the win. Weiner had a total of 19 points for the game…the only Clown in double figures.
    Again, Karen, thank you for your comment.

  8. Karen: Newspaper research would likely be the best way to learn more about the Carolina Clowns. Because these events occurred after 1923 (an important date regarding copyright) there are two possibilities: North Carolina Newspapers on Digital NC ( or Access is free to Digital NC; here’s a link to search I just performed that yielded 12 results (although a quick glance suggested that some may be false hits): is a subscription website, but researchers who use one of the UNC-Chapel Hill libraries may search North Carolina papers for free. Your local library my also provide access to the website. My search on pulled up 7,400+ results, but most are false hits (for example, it found “down” instead of “Clown” or “Statesville Clowns”). Nonetheless, it did turn up several correct hits.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *